These are the 3 US airlines you should aim to fly—and these 2 I’d avoid

A ranking of the best domestic US airlines

Delta airplanes on tarmac
GUIDE: Using Points
DIFFICULTY: Easy
TIME TO READ: 6 minutes
POSTED: June 7, 2019
UPDATED: June 7, 2019
LOYALTY PROGRAMS: Relevant to Multiple Programs

During my four years of living in The States, I’ve taken a whole lot of domestic flights.

Given so many of our readers visit North America, I wanted to share my ranking of the best (and worst) airlines for domestic US travel.

1. JetBlue

This is a fantastic carrier, but the only problem is they don’t fly many places!

Travellers from New Zealand are most likely to access their hubs in New York JFK (when visiting the Big Apple), Orlando (for Disneyworld), Fort Lauderdale (for Caribbean cruises) and Long Beach (which is closer to Disneyland than LAX).

Jetblue airplanes

JetBlue tends to be well-regarded by US travellers

They consistently have the most legroom in Economy Class (32-34 inches of seat pitch) and I love that they have free, unlimited high-speed internet. In my experience, the connection speeds tend to be very impressive.

On top of that, JetBlue has arguably the best domestic Business Class within the US with their Mint Class. This cabin flies coast-to-coast, to/from the Caribbean and potentially to London in the coming years. They often have the lowest cash fares of any carrier on these routes but note that lounge access is not included (so you’ll want a Priority Pass card for that).

JetBlue Mint Class

JetBlue’s Mint Class has sliding privacy doors

It is best to credit your JetBlue flights to Emirates Skywards, which is an American Express Membership Rewards partner.

2. Delta

If you’re looking for the best of the three legacy carriers—the others being American Airlines and United— Delta definitely comes out on top.

Delta aircrafts on tarmac

Delta generally maintains an excellent reputation amongst its customers

In my mind, they consistently excel in friendly customer service, generous food options and an expansive network.

As a Velocity partner, you and earn and redeem Velocity Points on Delta flights. Those with Velocity Gold status or above will get Delta SkyClub access as well as Sky Priority benefits like priority check-in and boarding. Delta lounges are generally really good.

Two downsides to Delta: its SkyMiles frequent flyer programme is terrible (credit your flights to Velocity instead), and American Airlines and United have better lounges for international passengers.

3. Southwest

This Texas-based airline is actually the third-largest US carrier by passengers carried, ahead of United. They have an expansive network, focussing on the eastern half of the US, The South and California. Southwest expanded to Hawaii in March 2019.

Southwest Route Map as of May 2019

Southwest’s route map in the US and into Latin America and the Caribbean

They’re the airline I fly the most often, given that they operate over 1 in 3 flights from my home base of Austin, Texas.

Southwest is the only domestic US carrier that includes free checked baggage—and you can take two pieces per person.

Southwest planes on tarmac

Southwest planes on the hot Austin Airport tarmac – can you see the texan flag?

The airline is unique in that it does not have pre-assigned seating. Rather, you’ll want to jump on the Southwest app or website right on 24 hours before departure to check-in. You’ll be assigned a number, e.g. A13, B24 or C57, and will board in that order. Families with children under six can board in between the first two groups (A and B).

Pricing used to be cheaper on Southwest (compared to other airlines), but that’s no longer the case in my opinion. Also, it’s hard to compare prices as Southwest is the only airline that does not show its prices through Google Flights (you have to click through to the Southwest site).

Google Flights Southwest results

Southwest prices do not show up in Google Flights

4. Alaska Airlines

First of all, let’s talk about this airline’s frequent flyer programmeit’s my favourite in the US and the world. Redemption rates are very reasonable compared to most other programmes and you can pick up Alaska miles by crediting your Qantas flights to them and/or purchasing miles during promotions.

Alaska airplane on tarmac

Alaska is a great airline but their reach is limited

In my opinion, Alaska shines with superior customer service and generous legroom. They would also be one of my companies of choice to get between Hawaii and the US mainland.

However, even though they merged with Virgin America in 2017, they are still very West Coast-centric, so that limits opportunities to fly on them.

5. American Airlines

I think AA gets a pretty bad rap a lot of the time, but they aren’t as bad as people make out.

Travellers will appreciate the ability to earn and redeem Qantas Points. Plus, those with Qantas Gold status or above will get Admirals Club access in addition to oneworld Sapphire or Emerald benefits.

American Airlines airplane on tarmac

American Airlines has extensive infrastructure but needs to lift its game

Given LAX is a hub for AA (as it is for Delta and United), those travelling on AA services to/from New Zealand will enjoy easy connections.

My main gripe with AA is that the customer service standards can vary wildly.

6. United Airlines

Given that United flies from Auckland to San Francisco, domestic connections are relatively streamlined.

United Airlines Plane on tarmac

United’s fares are competitive, but its reputation requires mending

United is part of the world’s largest alliance, Star Alliance, meaning you can earn and redeem Airpoints Dollars, Singapore Airlines KrisFlyer miles and Avianca LifeMiles.

Furthermore, those with Star Alliance Gold status will also get access to United Clubs. However, the lounges located overseas in places like London Heathrow and Hong Kong are much better than the domestic versions.

I’ve flown United quite a lot. My advice is to go in with the expectation of average customer service.

7. Spirit

I’ve only flown this airline once—from Dallas to San Diego back in 2015—and I actually received the best customer service I ever have on a domestic US flight. However, I think that was an anomaly as this ultra-low-cost carrier’s reputation is pretty shocking.

You’ll get a no-frills product with often inconvenient departure times. You’ll also need to pay for any larger carry-on and checked bags, which can significantly increase the price of a ticket.

Spirit baggage fees

Adding a full-size carry-on as well as one checked bag more than doubles the price of this Las Vegas to Los Angeles flight

Having said that, the cheapest way to get more room on a domestic flight in the US is to fly Spirit and purchase a Big Front Seat. You won’t get First Class service, but you’ll get a recliner seat in a 2-2 configuration (like in Qantas and Virgin Australia 737 Business Class).

Spirit Big Front Seat

This larger seat is available from Las Vegas to Los Angeles for only US$24 more—that’s worth it, in my opinion

8. Frontier

My advice: avoid avoid avoid. This is the worst-rated US airline on SKYTRAX, but they also have the cheapest fares—often by a lot.

This ultra-low-cost carrier has undergone rapid growth in the past few years, but it is quite unreliable and suffers from atrocious customer service.

Frontier Airplane taking off

My advice is to avoid flying Frontier where possible

In May 2018, I was scheduled to fly from Austin to Ontario (in between LA and Palm Springs). They’re the only airline to operate this route and I got a cheap fare. With a 6pm scheduled departure, we had a ‘rolling delay’ every 30 minutes until finally six hours later, at midnight, the flight was cancelled.

I had to overnight in a hotel near the airport and fly via Dallas with American Airlines the next day. And I’m not the only one with a story like that.

Buyer beware. Think Tigerair—but with less frequencies, meaning if your flight is cancelled, your alternatives are limited.

Summing up: which are the best domestic US airlines?

Here is my ranking:

  1. JetBlue
  2. Delta
  3. Southwest
  4. Hawaiian Airlines
  5. Alaska Airlines
  6. American Airlines
  7. United Airlines
  8. Sun Country Airlines
  9. Allegiant Air
  10. Spirit Airlines
  11. Frontier Airlines

Whilst I haven’t personally flown Hawaiian Airlines, Sun Country Airlines or Allegiant Air yet, I’ve added them into the rankings with some help from passengers’ reviews on SKYTRAX.

And let me continue with some more specific awards:

  • Best for customer service: JetBlue and Delta
  • Best for legroom: JetBlue and Alaska
  • Best Business Class: JetBlue and Delta
  • Best Economy Class: JetBlue and Delta
  • Best for Airpoints Gold and Elite status holders: United
  • Best for Qantas elite status holders: Alaska Airlines and American Airlines
  • Best for Velocity elite status holders: Delta
  • Best for families: Southwest
  • Best for the West Coast: Southwest, Alaska Airlines and Southwest
  • Best for the East Coast: JetBlue, Delta and Southwest
  • Best for Hawaii: Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines
  • Best for Latin America: American Airlines and United
  • Best for the Caribbean: JetBlue and American Airlines

Other tips to make the most of your trip to the US

Which is your favourite (or least favourite) US airline and why? Share in the comments below.

Supplementary images courtesy of respective airlines

These are the 3 US airlines you should aim to fly—and these 2 I’d avoid was last modified: June 7th, 2019 by Matt Moffitt